grumpycandycandy in Japan

Friday, February 16, 2007

Totoro and others


The other day we saw the famous Miyasaki animation "my neighbor Totoro" (1988) on DVD. I know it is a classic, but I couldn't help being disappointed.

As a child in France I used to watch plenty of Japanese animation series, because that's what they were showing on TV those days. I was a big fan of these 70's or early 80's Japanese anime' like Captain Future (capitaine Flam), UFO Robot Grendizer (Goldorak), Uchu kaizoku Captain Harlock (Albator), Heidi, and of course Candy-Candy (the nice one, not the grumpy one) etc..

I also like some of the other films by Miyasaki such as Porco Rosso, Castle in the Sky or Spirited Away, but there are several things about Totoro that left me with a taste of "huh?":

- Totoro isn't lovable at all, if you ask me. If I were a child I would'nt want to pat him, I think I'd rather run away as fast as possible.
- The cat-bus seemed out of place in this film and was used as a cheep trick at the end of the film.
- The two little girls were way too loud and screaming all the time. This seems to be a hallmark of Miyasaki who probably has gender-related issues. (I don't know if Heidi and Clara were screaming in the Japanese version of Heidi, but in the French one they didn't).
- The grandma. Is it a rule in rural Japan that when you move in to a new house the neighbor grandma comes to clean your house and cook for you? Hum...
- And also, there was no sign of a plot. Of course it is for children, but come on...

Anyway, I didn't come across a single bad review for this animation, only praise. So if there are Totoro fans out there, feel free to call me cold-hearted and explain me what I didn't get.

1 Comments:

  • Indeed people here love Totoro. They even build the real house of the Satsuki and May and people were crazy about it.

    http://kino-ie.net/genba_071.html

    By Anonymous Anonymous, At 9:16 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]



<< Home